« Portfolio Assessment in the ELA Classroom | Main | Five Lies We Tell Our Students - #2: "You have to learn the rules before you can break them." »


Dana Huff

I get so tired of being asked how many sentences to write. I can't remember that I've ever counted sentences when I grade.

Bronwyn G

I thought there were only 3-5 sentences in a paragraph, but I'll give that a miss.

J. Schlichtig

I hate having students ask me this question. I don't ever remember asking it or hearing another student ask it when I was in school. Now, when a student asks me, I just respond with: "I don't know. You haven't written the paragraph yet. When you finish it, come over and show me. I can give you a better idea at that time."


Kudos! Thank you! Gracias!

I grade by content, not by length. When students ask me how long a paper or response should be, I tell them GIGO. It's a computer science term that means "Garbage in, Garbage out." If you give me garbage to read, you'll get a garbage grade. I think they would rather have a sentence/page requirement because this technique forces them to evaluate their own work rather than do word count in Word.

The comments to this entry are closed.

My Photo

NY Times Education Section

Blog powered by Typepad